Asylum Challenges, Debates and Reforms. How Germany, Poland, Portugal and Sweden have developed their asylum systems since 2015

Publications

25 May 2021

Labour, Migration and Social Policies

External Publications

Agnieszka Kulesa

Download publication

Agnieszka Kulesa

Lead Social Sciences Researcher
Dr Agnieszka Kulesa is the Lead Social Sciences Researcher at CASE. She supports business development and oversees and contributes to research and analytical projects. Having joined CASE in 2018 as an economist, she served as Vice-President of the Management Board from 2021 to 2024. Agnieszka has authored or co-authored numerous publications, including peer-reviewed articles and reports for European institutions such as the European Commission (EC), the European Parliament (EP), the European Committee of the Regions (CoR) and the European Economic and Social Committee (EESC).

Articles from this author:
- The Territorial Dimension of the Reform and Growth Facility for the Western Balkans
  This report, commissioned by the European Committee of the Regions, provides an early-stage assessment of the territorial dimension of the Reform and Growth Facility (RGF) for the Western Balkans (2024–2027
- Migrant workers coming to Poland from other European Union member states. Barriers, difficulties, and possible courses of action
- Capacity building for local and regional authorities in the light of the Ukraine Facility (Pillar III)
Author’s articles

When a million people sought refuge in Europe in 2015 due to the wars and violent conflicts in the Middle East and North Africa, the structural deficiencies in the already flawed Common European Asylum System (CEAS) became evident. This publication analyses how the asylum systems in Germany, Poland, Portugal and Sweden have evolved since 2015, which reforms were introduced, and which challenges remain.

2021 marks the tenth year of the dreadful war in Syria. A war that has forcibly displaced millions of Syrians from their homes, destabilised the entire region and impacted world politics. In 2015, the severe consequences of the wars and violent conflicts in Syria and the MENA region (Middle East and North Africa) started to directly affect the European Union as well. The sudden increase in arrivals at the EU’s external borders painfully exposed the inherent weaknesses of the CEAS. Crucially, this resulted from the faulty construction of the Dublin regulation, which stipulates that – in most cases – the Member States of first entry are responsible for processing asylum applications. The Dublin regulation’s inadequate design has caused disproportionate pressures on EU Member states with external borders in the south, namely Greece, Italy, Spain, Malta and Cyprus.

Despite efforts to strengthen the EU’s ability to act, key challenges to the CEAS remain. A comprehensive agreement on the reform of the Dublin regulation is still missing, as finding a solution on solidarity and responsibility sharing between EU Member States continues to be the most difficult task.

In the absence of a comprehensive agreement on the EU level, much has happened in Member States since 2015. In the four country studies, published here, the authors analyse the asylum challenges, debates and reforms that have taken place in Germany, Poland, Portugal and Sweden. The studies highlight the specific situation of each asylum system. How have the four EU Member States experienced the sudden rise of asylum applications in the EU, especially between 2015 and 2016? How have they sought to reform their asylum systems since then? Which hurdles have they faced in the process and which challenges have not been solved so far?This publication is part of the initiative Making Asylum Systems Work in Europe, which the Bertelsmann Stiftung and the Migration Policy Institute Europe started in cooperation with the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation in Portugal, the Swedish Migration Studies Delegation (Delmi), the Institute for Public Affairs (IPA) in Poland and the International Centre for Migration Policy Development (ICMPD). The initiative aims to contribute to the capacity building of national asylum systems so they can function more effectively.

The chapter on Poland is authored by Agnieszka Kulesa, CASE economist.

Related publications

No results

Asylum Challenges, Debates and Reforms. How Germany, Poland, Portugal and Sweden have developed their asylum systems since 2015

Agnieszka Kulesa

Articles from this author:

Related publications

1 Subscribe to selected mailing lists

We send newsletters in Polish and English. The content in both languages differs. You can choose to subscribe to one or both languages.

2 Confirm your email and accept the clause

Asylum Challenges, Debates and Reforms. How Germany, Poland, Portugal and Sweden have developed their asylum systems since 2015

Agnieszka Kulesa

Articles from this author:

Related publications

Join the community of informed readers. Subscribe to our newsletter.

Newsletter CASE

1 Subscribe to selected mailing lists

We send newsletters in Polish and English. The content in both languages differs. You can choose to subscribe to one or both languages.

2 Confirm your email and accept the clause